65 Product Ratings and Reviews
About this Company
Let us take care of your online seafood needs. With such a wide range of fresh and wild caught seafood, You can trust us to deliver you with pure untreated fish portions, with tools and tips for quick easy preparation, and with honest information about the benefits you are receiving from Sizzlefish products.
Enjoy Premium seafood delivered from Sizzlefish. FREE shipping on every order!
Linda B - 06/07/2020
The tuna was good but we were disappointed in the cut. Wish I had known it was cut only about 1/4 inch thick. Pretty hard to cook to a medium rare.
Very easy process. Customer reviews helped me decide on you for my order. Enjoyed getting the 10% discount as a Welcome to new customers. It convinced me to order 2 products instead of one.
Daryn R - 06/03/2020
I thought the portions would be thicker and what I got look like tuna steaks you get at the store and nothing like what you advertised in the pics
I appreciate an la carte menu without a membership
Sue G - 05/25/2020
The freshest, most exquisite, delectable tuna you can imagine - used it in 'blackened tuna', searing it barely 2 minutes per side - should be very pink in the middle. Thank you for providing such a quality product.
Ed - 05/14/2020
Really delicious. Frankly, we were shocked at how delicious. Great packaging ensures the product stayed perfect. Clean and delicate Ahi taste. No need to cook. Eat like a shark!
05/14/2020 - NY
Simple easy to use shopping cart. AND you proved to me you know fish. Thank you
Elda S - 05/10/2020
This was a gift to my son and family. They absolutely loved it and want to order more. Sizzlefish was very prompt and efficient in getting it shipped coast-to-coast to them. I would definitely order from them again.
05/10/2020 - IN
Jason A - 05/01/2020
I have bought tuna from 2 or 3 other places. This is the only place I will buy from in the future. The packaging and shipping are excellent.
Great, except this is the third time I have ordered and I could not log into my account. Weird.
Paula L - 04/26/2020
Enjoyed very much. Whole family liked !!
04/26/2020 - MA
The seafood was great. Delivered in a timely fashion. The sales people who I spoke with went out of their way to change a delivery address for me and it was greatly appreciated
Kelly S - 04/23/2020
I made a tuna tartare and it was delicious! This high quality Ahi Tuna was exceptional. Looking forward to having this again!
04/23/2020 - GA
This was my first purchase with Sizzlefish and I am very pleased with the purchasing experience, short delivery time (even during the Coronavirus pandemic) and most of all the exceptional quality of the seafood. I purchased, and have tried, the Ahi Tuna, Halibut and Sea Scallops. All were phenomenal!
Laura E - 04/22/2020
This Ahi is definitely sushi grade. I quickly seared the edges and added it to an asian stir-fry bowl and it was perfect.
Jennifer I - 04/21/2020
My husband and I recently tried Tuna Poke bowls and enjoyed them. We bought this Tuna from Sizzlefish and started making our own at home. The tuna is perfect for this and it's not so bad sheltering at home with sushi ❤.
04/21/2020 - OH
I have been buying from Sizzlefish for about 2 years. Love their product, it's always delivered completely frozen and is delicious.
John C - 04/21/2020
Tuna was great. My disappointment is in the Customer Service. My Tuna did not ship same day as per their FAQs. My order was in at 10:44am eastern time on a Tuesday but didn't ship until next day. I screwed up on the delivery address and sent a email to contact us box and still haven't received a response. Luckily FedEx came through for me. Product was very good and dry ice did it's job. I will try a couple other Competitors before deciding who will be my go to.
04/21/2020 - IN
see my review
Dee O - 04/14/2020
I was nervous since the delivery took a bit long with the current situation. When I received it, it was frozen solid and perfect and tasted delicious. The company stayed in touch with me daily to ease my frustration. I will surely continue to order from Sizzlefish.
04/14/2020 - PA
Easy to navigate and lots of information. Hope it is as good as it looks.
Pauline J - 04/11/2020
I am very satisfied with the Yellowfin Tuna. Delivered Fresh frozen and when cooked, absolutely five star quality. I'll be ordering this again.
04/11/2020 - NM
Easy ordering. Quick delivery.. Well packaged but need to be careful with the dry ice! Excellent size portions. High quality fish Absolutely delicious.
David R - 03/31/2020
The ahi came as very thin steaks. I would have preferred sashimi grade ahi blocks, which would then be versatile enough to make poke or seared ahi as shown in the photo. I did make poke out of a couple of steaks, but it wasn't sashimi grade and therefore some pieces weren't as tender as they should have been. Good, but far from great.
03/31/2020 - NM
The purchase using the website was easy and the delivery was efficient. The fish was still well frozen when it arrived.
Why Trust Verified Reviews?
Verified Reviews are real, authentic reviews collected from actual paying customers, using Shopper Approved's Verified Review Platform. When reviews are Verified by Shopper Approved, you know that you can trust them to make better buying decisions.
Unverified Reviews on the other hand, are reviews collected by Open Review platforms that allow anyone to leave a review, without any validation or proof of purchase. Unfortunately, most reviews you read online are Unverified Reviews, and can't be trusted.
As a consumer, here's how you can tell the difference:
Verified Reviews from Verified Review Platforms like Shopper Approved, have much higher review counts and higher overall Star ratings, because they attempt to collect reviews from every single paying customer.
Unverified Reviews from Open Review Platforms, tend to have much lower review counts and more negative Star ratings, because people with bad experiences are primarily those who leave reviews. This often creates a misleading, inaccurate portrayal of a companies true reputation.
So, when searching for Verified Reviews, look for the name you know you can trust. Shopper Approved.
Are you a Business?
See What Shopper Approved
Can Do For You