sizzlefish.com Reviews
About this CompanyLet us take care of your online seafood needs. With such a wide range of fresh and wild caught seafood, You can trust us to deliver you with pure untreated fish portions, with tools and tips for quick easy preparation, and with honest information about the benefits you are receiving from Sizzlefish products.
Enjoy Premium seafood delivered from Sizzlefish. FREE shipping on every order!
Back to Product Reviews65 Product Ratings and Reviews
4.7
Overall Star
Rating
About this Company
Let us take care of your online seafood needs. With such a wide range of fresh and wild caught seafood, You can trust us to deliver you with pure untreated fish portions, with tools and tips for quick easy preparation, and with honest information about the benefits you are receiving from Sizzlefish products.
Enjoy Premium seafood delivered from Sizzlefish. FREE shipping on every order!
Elizabeth U - 03/29/2020
Unfortunately when I ordered the Tuna it was backordered. But someone called and refunded me that day. I will try and order again in a week. Thanks Sizzlefish!
1 Company Review
03/29/2020 - AL
I will continue to order from Sizzlefish. My only wish is that I can do add on with my regular subscription. If there is a way to do that I couldn't figure it out. All my seafood has been so fresh and shipped so fast and safely.
Cherie T - 03/28/2020
The ahi tuna was very tasty. I seared the tuna in the same pan that I had seared the scallops. Best I’ve ever had.
03/28/2020
Very reliable delivery and safety. I feel I'm an getting fish from a clean source of water and from a company that is sanitary and pays attention to every detail.
Valerie A - 03/11/2020
The tuna was exceptional in look, taste and smell. Made excellent sashimi for my husband's birthday!
03/11/2020 - OH
Ordering was very easy and the tuna arrived well packaged. The tuna was delicious (we ate it as sashimi).
thomas J - 03/10/2020
My wife never thought she liked Tuna and never served rare but once we started buying this top grade tuna and cooking in for around 30 seconds on each side and serving with different sauce it has become both our favorite dishes
03/10/2020 - NC
Quick delivery and great products
Andrea T - 02/20/2020
Not the best I had.
02/20/2020 - NJ
Great products, great customer service.
Carolyn L - 02/09/2020
Excellent Ahi. Very fresh, packaged perfectly. Will definitely buy again.
02/09/2020 - KY
Very easy and love the free shipping! Excellent quality, packaged well and wonderful fresh taste. Definitely recommend the Ahi Tuna. Shrimp and Scallops are great too.
Jen - 01/22/2020
I use these all year for Tuna Sashimi..it is so good and fresh.
01/22/2020 - AR
Their order processing is timely, packaged well, and great for storing.
Sheila A - 12/20/2019
Sushi grade tuna, great packaging and delivery!
12/20/2019 - NC
Great experience, great product, great packaging, great delivery
Sheila A - 12/20/2019
Sushi grade tuna, packaged and delivered on time! Great gift!
12/20/2019 - NC
Great experience!
don C - 10/14/2019
only thing better is to catch it yourself!!
10/14/2019
site is easy to navigate prices are fair quality is top notch. repeat customer!!
Liliana F - 09/13/2019
Sashimi Quality, plan on having a sushi party soon! Value, Quality, Price
09/13/2019 - AZ
Great Fish!!!!! So excited to try the lobster and Ahi. My Sister bought me a gift card for our anniversary. So excited to get our yummy seafood! ... We enjoyed some Lobster and Ahi with Family it was Amazing!!! Customer Support is Amazing!!!! Extremely Happy with All Entities of Sizzlefish!!!!!!!
Benjamin G - 07/16/2019
Bought as a mother's day gift and we all loved the tuna... as good as anything had at a restaurant. Minimal connective tissue and the packaging for shipping was stellar. I was able to make excellent poke bowls for our family of five three times... certainly less expensive than if we had bought something similar out.
07/16/2019 - AZ
Shopping was easy... I like that I do not have to create another account. Overall a well designed site.
ElizabethL - 06/22/2019
Delicious. Tuna tasted fresh and came conveniently packaged.
06/22/2019 - CA
Easy to order. Arrived well packaged
Rita - 06/19/2019
A little pricey but delicious!
06/19/2019 - WY
Easy, fast, and convenient!
Nichole S - 05/10/2019
In the midwest we struggle to get fish that can be eaten raw. My wife prefers this tuna cooked medium, but I like it rare. Really rare. It still tastes surprisingly good fully cooked, which I am not used to. Around here if I fully cook one of our typical frozen tunas, it ends up dry and tough. So I didn't believe my wife about how good her fully cooked tuna was until I tried it for myself. My serving of tuna is covered in Cajun seasoning, then seared on both sides for a couple of minutes. It is totally raw in the middle and we have been serving it with a marmalade sauce that tops off the dish perfectly. My kitten gets a little bit of raw tuna every time I eat one. No complaints there either! LOL!
05/10/2019 - IL
We have had some issues with Shipping, we don't always get what we ordered. But we report the issues and SizzleFish always treats us right! We started out at OceanFish.com but their subscription model just doesn't work for us. They could only get us 4 servings of fish every week between Thursday and Sat. That schedule just made it very dificult for us to plan dinners for the week. With SizzleFish, we order $300 worth of fish at once, and we can plan dinners out for the entire month! Keep up the great work, we dig you guys!
Erica S - 04/09/2019
Hands down the best tuna I have ever had. I ate the first two blocks raw, without even seasoning or sides. So fresh!
04/09/2019 - DC
Nichole S - 03/05/2019
They mean it, you can eat it raw! You will not have tuna this wonderful prior or again if you are buying or eating any other tuna!! It's perfect tasting for a great price!! Nothing beats this tuna!
03/05/2019 - IL
Sizzlefish's customer service is impeccable!
Nichole S - 02/13/2019
This is some of the best Tuna we have ever ate. We love fish, and living in IL puts a damper on that, there is no fresh fish around. Sizzlefish is the best, they preportion some of the best tuna I have ever tasted. I dont think it matters how you eat it, its wonderful! Bake it, fry it, raw it, its the best! No other tuna compares, and I love my preportioned I can just grab quick to thaw.
02/13/2019 - IL
While I read most of what I needed from the website, when it came to just purchasing in bulk or subscriptions I had a few remaining questions. It was nice to know they came in preportioned sizes and they freeze at its most freshes point. So frozen it comes and lasts for 1yr in freezer. Now lets be honest, their fish is so wonderfully good, it will not last a year in your freezer. I will only ever buy Sizzlefish
Olin T - 10/13/2018
I would love to give this five stars. This is my second time ordering their ahi tuna blocks, and the first time it was perfect. It was some of the best fish I've ever had. We especially like to use it for poke bowls. Anyway, this time two of the blocks were open and had lost the vacuum seal. I didn't think much because of the super low temperature. I thawed four blocks that day including the two that were compromised. I thawed the blocks according to directions as usual. When I went to use them later that day, two of them were odd colored and smelled fishy...not what I wanted. The other two were great (a little fishy from their neighbors but still good). I wish I had taken pictures, but I was too excited when the package came. I would recommend to a friend but caution them on the packaging.
10/13/2018
Easy shopping just missing masago :)
Maureen S - 08/11/2018
Made great sushi!!!
08/11/2018 - NC
Ordering was easy, fish was delicious and I will order again!!!
Why Trust Verified Reviews?
Verified Reviews are real, authentic reviews collected from actual paying customers, using Shopper Approved's Verified Review Platform. When reviews are Verified by Shopper Approved, you know that you can trust them to make better buying decisions.
Unverified Reviews on the other hand, are reviews collected by Open Review platforms that allow anyone to leave a review, without any validation or proof of purchase. Unfortunately, most reviews you read online are Unverified Reviews, and can't be trusted.
As a consumer, here's how you can tell the difference:
Verified Reviews from Verified Review Platforms like Shopper Approved, have much higher review counts and higher overall Star ratings, because they attempt to collect reviews from every single paying customer.
Unverified Reviews from Open Review Platforms, tend to have much lower review counts and more negative Star ratings, because people with bad experiences are primarily those who leave reviews. This often creates a misleading, inaccurate portrayal of a companies true reputation.
So, when searching for Verified Reviews, look for the name you know you can trust. Shopper Approved.
Are you a Business?
See What Shopper Approved
Can Do For You
sizzlefish.com
© 2023 ShopperApproved.com. All rights reserved. Learn more about Shopper Approved.
This Shopper Approved Customer Rating and Review Certificate was generated using independent survey information gathered by Shopper Approved, LLC © 2023