GemsNY.com is family-owned and operates as an online seller of color gemstones, diamonds, and bespoke jewelry such as engagement rings, men’s & women’s rings, bands, earrings, pendants, necklaces and bracelets. We have more than 50,000 gemstones in our inventory which are entirely owned by us. We procure gemstones directly from the source to eliminate middlemen, helping us provide unparalleled pricing and choices for our customers. We price match other vendors because we know you will not find a better price anywhere else!

Our jewelry is made to order around beautiful gemstones selected by our customers. All of our jewelry is made in New York City with great attention and highest quality standards. We back our jewelry with our lifetime warranty. Our customers can be assured 100% satisfaction with our hassle-free 30 day return policy and free domestic return shipping. We ship throughout the United States and to almost every country in the world.

Our offerings include the following:

Products:

  • Loose Diamonds and Diamond Jewelry
  • Loose Gemstones and Gemstone Jewelry
  • Services:

  • Custom Jewelry
  • Jewelry cleaning and maintenance
  • Rhodium plating
  • Ring Sizing, engraving etc.
  • Though our parent company was founded in 1988, GemsNY started operating in 2005 as the online extension of our traditional gems & jewelry business. We are located in New York City at 20 West, 47th Street where we invite you to visit by appointment.

    Filter

    2,568 Verified Customer Reviews

    2,568 Customer Ratings and Reviews

    Shopper Approved collects trusted reviews from customers who have made a verified purchase.

    4.9

    Overall Star
    Rating

    5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    2259
    (88%)
    4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    253
    (9.9%)
    3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    45
    (1.8%)
    2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    9
    (0.4%)
    1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    2
    (0.1%)

    Would Recommend
    4.9
    5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    2252
    4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    218
    3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    50
    2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    6
    1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    8
    Customer Service
    4.8
    5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    366
    4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    28
    3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    11
    2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    3
    1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
    4
    SHOW DETAILS

    5-star reviews
    2,250+

    5-star reviews

    9 years collecting reviews

    Video Reviews

    View All
    Filter
    M
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Miranda O.
    Today , CA

    I like designing the ring.

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    K
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Karon N.
    1 day ago , ME

    I loved your great selection and prices. Thanks

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    B
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Ben T.
    2 days ago , TX

    I wouldn't order from the website again. The price was very expensive compared to the quality of the merchandise.

    Would Recommend
    3/5
    Bezel Set Solitaire Pendant Setting
    Bezel Set Solitaire Pendant Setting
    Read more reviews about this product

    2 days ago

    Much smaller than the price reflected. Not sure it was the quality promised.


    J
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jason M.
    2 days ago , CT

    Easy and clear

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    D
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer David D.
    2 days ago , LA

    So far pleased

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    R
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer RONALD S.
    3 days ago , AZ

    It was ok.

    Would Recommend
    4/5
    Customer Service
    3/5
    Prong Set Round Diamonds Ring Setting (0.26cttw)
    Prong Set Round Diamonds Ring Setting (0.26cttw)
    Read more reviews about this product

    3 days ago

    Wife's first Ruby...

    Although it was a beautiful ring the band was real skinny, I thought it would be a little wider like the picture portrayed.


    A
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Aleksandr L.
    3 days ago , FL

    returning customer to GemsNY- always a great experience and top notch products with certificates of authenticity and appraisal as well as the best pricing around

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    K
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Kevin
    4 days ago , CA

    Ordering process was very easy.

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    G
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer GERALD B.
    4 days ago , NV

    Item was delivered to FedEx location for my pickup since there are "porch pirates" in the area and one can not always depend on FedEx to obtan a signature.

    Would Recommend
    5/5
    Solitaire Pendant Setting
    Solitaire Pendant Setting
    Read more reviews about this product

    4 days ago

    The best of both worlds.

    Pendant setting is perfect for showing the gem and also protecting it.

    Solitaire Pendant Setting
    Solitaire Pendant Setting
    Read more reviews about this product

    4 days ago

    An heirloom for sure

    Bought this as a gift and will give the gift in about 30 days. Am sure that she will love the pendant. Bought the gem here even though I will be in Tanzania is less than a year. This is definetly an heirloom for my granddaughter.


    J
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer jerry G.
    4 days ago , NM

    seems upfront so far. we'll see what the ruby looks like when it gets here.

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    S
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer steven K.
    4 days ago , NJ

    Excellent customer service and high quality stones

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    A
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Andrew B.
    6 days ago , NY

    Very easy to figure out what you'd like. I do wish they had more mens rings setting options.

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    J
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jeff
    6 days ago , NM

    Great

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    O
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Orson S.
    6 days ago , FL

    Great Service

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    N
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer nathan B.
    1 week ago , AR

    very user friendly

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    R
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Rachelle C.
    1 week ago , VA

    C

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    C
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Carmine G.
    1 week ago , NY

    grate

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    C
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Cathy R.
    1 week ago , AZ

    I have bought several items from GemsNY, and have had all of them evaluated separately by other jewelers. I received what I payed for and at exceptional value. I will definitely purchase from them again.

    Would Recommend
    5/5

    L
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Laurentiu T.
    1 week ago , CA

    Great

    Would Recommend
    5/5
    Halo Ring Setting With Pave Set Round Diamonds (0.35cttw)
    Halo Ring Setting With Pave Set Round Diamonds (0.35cttw)
    Read more reviews about this product

    1 week ago

    Amazing

    Halo Ring Setting With Pave Set Round Diamonds (0.35cttw)
    Halo Ring Setting With Pave Set Round Diamonds (0.35cttw)
    Read more reviews about this product

    1 week ago

    Stunning stone!


    P
    Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Pablo L.
    1 week ago , WA

    I buy Shiny rock, it fun, me use shiny to attract female!

    Would Recommend
    5/5
    1.12 cts. Tanzanite Cushion
    1.12 cts. Tanzanite Cushion
    Read more reviews about this product

    1 week ago

    Just like the picture, looks great

    Untreated 1.07 cts. Purple Sapphire Cushion
    Untreated 1.07 cts. Purple Sapphire Cushion
    Read more reviews about this product

    1 week ago

    One tiny inclusion in a noticable spot, but otherwise good, great cut and color, just a bit away from 5 ⭐


    Are you a Business?

    See What Shopper Approved
    Can Do For You

    Inactive Business
    Website Directions Phone

    © 2023 ShopperApproved.com. All rights reserved. Learn more about Shopper Approved.

    This Shopper Approved Customer Rating and Review Certificate was generated using independent survey information gathered by Shopper Approved, LLC © 2023