In 1962, a young couple, Rosanne and Bill Fitzula, Jr., opened a variety store to serve the needs of the mostly middle class Italian families that lived in the area. Located 90 miles North of New York City on the western shores of the Hudson River in the quaint Village of West Haverstraw, they began their life journey together. The store fronted Railroad Avenue and Bill and Rosanne lived upstairs allowing them to work side by side in their labor of love. Over the next 10 years their store prospered and their little family grew. They raised two handsome boys, Billy, Freddy and one beautiful daughter Cindy.

In the early 1970's Bill decided to transform the variety store into a full fledged jewelry store and after years of night classes and endless training successfully converted their little store into a full service jewelry store focusing on diamonds and watches.

For the next 25 years Rosanne and Bill watched their children grow up, begin families of their own and tinkered with the inventory to match the changing needs of the locale community.

In 1997 under the capable direction of their son Billy they launched their first website. They were far ahead of their time and experimented constantly as they awaited the world to beat a small path to their door.

In 2000, Rosanne passed away, causing Bill to close down the store for three months. During those three months Bill reflected on his life, his lost love Rosanne and the wonderful family he had been blessed with. With the support and encouragement of his three children he once again made a change in the direction of the store. He decided the time was right to pursue a dream he and Rosanne had to focus their attention on the gifts and collectible market. For the next three years Bill and his children, all who worked part time as needed, transitioned the store from exclusively jewelry to primarily gifts and collectibles focusing on those hard to get pieces that weren’t readily available in the area.

By 2003 the neighborhood and the surrounding area had changed. The quaint little neighborhood made up of small family owned businesses had morphed into another suburb of New York City complete with fast food restaurants and giant box national retailers. It was once again time for a major change.

Bill decided to move his store to the little town of West Milford, NJ. Located in the "Heart of the Highlands". He once again has found the idyllic serenity that he once knew in the Village of West Haverstraw.

After spending 11 years in West Milford an opportunity to own their own building presented itself. With vision and foresight Bill and Billy purchased the old diner in Greenwood Lake, New York. They renovated the building adding a second floor which is used as their storage area. The grand opening of the new building was May 1, 2015. "We chose Greenwood Lake because it's a vibrant community," says Bill. "There are people walking downtown, kids playing on the field across the street and a lot of events that bring people together here." Billy added that he looks forward to being in Greenwood Lake for as long as his parents were in West Haverstraw.

"We welcome the Fitzula familty to Greenwood Lake," says Kevin Sweeney, President of the Greenwood Lake Chamber of Commerce. "They have done an outstanding job completely renovating the building they purchased and we thank them for thier investment in our downtown."

If you happen to find yourself in the area please stop in and say hello and take your time looking around the shop that Rosanne and Bill started 45 years ago. Don't rush, we are glad you've come and we are in no hurry to see you leave, as this is where we come to relax and enjoy life.

Bill and Billy Fitzula


3,135 Verified Customer Reviews

3,135 Customer Ratings and Reviews

Shopper Approved collects trusted reviews from customers who have made a verified purchase.


Overall Star

5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star

Customer Service
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star

5-star reviews

5-star reviews

8 years collecting reviews

Video Reviews

View All
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Chris P.
1 day ago , VA

Excellent every time. The Ganz gnomes are hard to find.

Product Choice

I'm completing a collection.

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Georgia S.
2 days ago , PA

Easy to use

Product Choice

Gave to friends….loved them…more friend want them

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Leek G.
2 days ago , CO

The site was efficient

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Sister C.
3 days ago , PA

Easy,and what I wanted was in stoc.

Product Choice

Because it is a great reminder about the power of prayer.

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Joy J.
3 days ago , KY

It was quick and easy. I found their website and ordered the item I wanted. It was shipped the next day and arrived quickly. It was packed securely and professionally. Excellent experience.

Product Choice

I had seen the frame online and thought it would be cute for a picture I have of my daughter dressed as Belle. Especially since we had just visited the Precious Moments Chapel.

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Margie B.
4 days ago , IL

Always a good experience shopping.

Product Choice

I saw them on another site and the price is much better here.

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer carol S.
4 days ago , PA

Love the Byers collection

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Julie L.
4 days ago , AL

Very easy

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer LOIS M.
4 days ago , CA

i like to give these out to friends

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Kerry H.
4 days ago , TX

Found things I haven't seen before

Product Choice

They are unique

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Shawn S.
4 days ago , OR

I enjoy finding items no longer available in national chain stores...

Product Choice

Peanuts fan

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Cassandra C.
5 days ago , PA

Very easy to use and quick delivery.

Product Choice

Bachelorette Party Gifting

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Julissa A.
6 days ago , TX

Quickest shipping ever!

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Kevin P.
6 days ago , TX

This was an easy purchase.

Product Choice

I am adding autumn scenery to my Halloween village.

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer BETTY L.
6 days ago , NC

Easy purchase, website is user friendly

Product Choice

Price, looking for this one item

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Peggy S.
1 week ago , SC


Product Choice


Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Gayle L.
1 week ago , OH

Love them

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer DENISE A.
1 week ago , NJ

Love your tiny charms

Product Choice


Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Robert S.
1 week ago , MA

Very easy to find what I was looking for

Product Choice

My wife collects them

Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Tammy M.
1 week ago , NC

I found exactly what I was looking for. Awesome

Product Choice

I needed a house flag to match my garden flag.

Are you a Business?

See What Shopper Approved
Can Do For You

Inactive Business
Website Directions Phone

© 2024 All rights reserved. Learn more about Shopper Approved.

This Shopper Approved Customer Rating and Review Certificate was generated using independent survey information gathered by Shopper Approved, LLC © 2024