ThePaperMillStore.com Reviews

About this Company

Great Papers. Fast Shipping. Low Prices. Real People.

Professionals and hobbyists alike have trusted The Paper Mill Store since 2004 to provide great papers at great prices, shipped fast and secure.

We're here to make your paper project easy and perfect. Choose from over 13,000 SKUs from more than 200 paper mill brands handled by attentive, dedicated professionals. With the majority of SKUs in-stock, most orders ship within 24 hours (usually same day).

In addition to thousands of brand-name papers, envelopes, card stocks and other products, we offer and array of custom services including paper cutting, perforating, scoring, drilling, envelope printing and custom watermarking. Samples and swatch books are available for most papers and free shipping is available.
 
Take advantage of our buyer rewards, reseller, 501c and military discount programs along with special offer promotions.

With decades of experience in the paper industry, our top-notch customer service, teamwork and attention to detail guarantees quality and professionalism in all we do.  

Our corporate office campus is located in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, along with a state-of-the-art 72,000-square-foot converting and distribution center in the heart of the "Paper Valley" in Neenah, Wisconsin.

Filter

20,935 Verified Customer Reviews

20,935 Customer Ratings and Reviews

Shopper Approved collects trusted reviews from customers who have made a verified purchase.

4.8

Overall Star
Rating

5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
17K+
(82.7%)
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2750
(13.1%)
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
683
(3.3%)
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
98
(0.5%)
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
93
(0.4%)

Would Buy Again
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
18K+
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2050
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
531
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
98
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
89
Would Recommend
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
17K+
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2486
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
726
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
113
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
111
Delivery Time
4.7
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4943
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
708
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
212
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
65
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
62
Product Satisfaction
4.7
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4967
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
681
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
214
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
43
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
85
Customer Service
4.6
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
597
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
95
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
34
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
16
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
25
Price Satisfaction
4.4
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
3669
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
1482
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
606
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
147
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
86
SHOW DETAILS

5-star reviews
17K+

5-star reviews

6 years collecting reviews
Filter
L
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Leslie R.
1 week ago , CA

Site is great, but couldn't edit the quantity at checkout. Had to start over.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Royal Sundance Brilliant White Card Stock - 18 x 12 in 80 lb Cover Felt Digital 250 per Package
Royal Sundance Brilliant White Card Stock - 18 x 12 in 80 lb Cover Felt Digital 250 per Package
Read more reviews about this product

1 week ago

Great ordering experience. Liked that I was able to get the paper cut to my specifications.


J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jule M.
1 week ago , texas

Great

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

A
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Amy G.
1 week ago

Quick shipping. Great product. Duty to come to Canada is insane!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
3/5
Delivery
5/5

J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jessica M.
1 week ago

Very straightforward & simple. Easy to process.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

R
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Rafael L.
1 week ago

ssd

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

C
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Cristena B.
1 week ago

love you all! I tell everyone about the paper mill store

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

E
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Emily O.
1 week ago

I am frustrated by how often my order has damage

Would Recommend
3/5
Would Buy Again
3/5

G
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Gary M.
1 week ago , Arizona

Thank you for the quality service!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
4/5
Delivery
5/5

A
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Audrey G.
1 week ago , South Carolina

My order placed and shipped smoothly and I was happy with the product. I appreciated that they offered samples of the paper before I committed to opening the full pack.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

CRANE'S LETTRA Pearl White Card Stock - 8 1/2 x 11 in 110 lb Cover Lettra Letterpress 100% Cott
CRANE'S LETTRA Pearl White Card Stock - 8 1/2 x 11 in 110 lb Cover Lettra Letterpress 100% Cott
Read more reviews about this product

1 week ago

Great paper!

Beautiful paper and easily printed on this with my Canon ink jet printer at home.


A
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer ANN S.
1 week ago

It was quick and easy.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

ASPIRE Petallics Pure Gold Paper - 8 1/2 x 11 in 81 lb Text Metallic C/2S 350 per Package
ASPIRE Petallics Pure Gold Paper - 8 1/2 x 11 in 81 lb Text Metallic C/2S 350 per Package
Read more reviews about this product

1 week ago

Very nice paper that fits our needs.


J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jesus M.
1 week ago

Was great

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

B
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Barbara S.
1 week ago

Ordering is easy. Customer service is excellent.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Royal Sundance Natural White Paper - 23 x 35 in 70 lb Text Felt  30% Recycled 1000 per Carton
Royal Sundance Natural White Paper - 23 x 35 in 70 lb Text Felt 30% Recycled 1000 per Carton
Read more reviews about this product

1 week ago

Great quality paper to work with.

Great quality paper to work with. It handles well with our printing system.


R
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Rhonda D.
1 week ago

Easy to find what I was looking for and place my order.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

C
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Chris C.
1 week ago

Great experience

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Joy G.
1 week ago

The Papermill Store had exactly what my client requested and the prices are great.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

H
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer HC
1 week ago

Overall my experience was great. However, I was sending holiday cards to 275 people and the envelopes came in batches of 250. I also got them addresses to each recipient. Last year, in this situation, they let me order the extra 25 but this year they said I'd have to order a whole other 250 envelopes just to get the additional 25 I needed. I didn't want to do this do I had to order separately from Amazon 25 envelopes and create labels which was a pain.

Would Recommend
4/5
Would Buy Again
4/5
Product Satisfaction
4/5
Price
5/5
Customer Service
4/5
Delivery
4/5

C
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Cindy B.
1 week ago

I’m able to get what I need in one place at decent prices.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

L
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Lina M.
1 week ago

Very positive. Good website.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

G
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer George W.
1 week ago

sO FAR SO GOOD

Would Recommend
4/5
Would Buy Again
4/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
4/5
Customer Service
4/5
Delivery
4/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Fine Impressions Hi White Folded Panel Cards - A6 (4 5/8 x 6 1/4 folded) 80 lb Cover Vellum - 250 pe
Fine Impressions Hi White Folded Panel Cards - A6 (4 5/8 x 6 1/4 folded) 80 lb Cover Vellum - 250 pe
Read more reviews about this product

1 week ago

Front panel has a rectangular depression not visible on the web portrayal.


L
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Lorraine C.
1 week ago , CA

Overall experience was fine. It took a while to figure out what was going on. I'm glad that you sell samples. I wasn't certain about the texture and weight of the Mohawk vellum, because the sample I had from another store (that no longer carries the color) was heavier.

Would Recommend
4/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
4/5
Price
4/5
Delivery
5/5

Are you a Business?

See What Shopper Approved
Can Do For You

Inactive Business
Website Directions Phone

© 2024 ShopperApproved.com. All rights reserved. Learn more about Shopper Approved.

This Shopper Approved Customer Rating and Review Certificate was generated using independent survey information gathered by Shopper Approved, LLC © 2024