ThePaperMillStore.com Reviews

About this Company

Great Papers. Fast Shipping. Low Prices. Real People.

Professionals and hobbyists alike have trusted The Paper Mill Store since 2004 to provide great papers at great prices, shipped fast and secure.

We're here to make your paper project easy and perfect. Choose from over 13,000 SKUs from more than 200 paper mill brands handled by attentive, dedicated professionals. With the majority of SKUs in-stock, most orders ship within 24 hours (usually same day).

In addition to thousands of brand-name papers, envelopes, card stocks and other products, we offer and array of custom services including paper cutting, perforating, scoring, drilling, envelope printing and custom watermarking. Samples and swatch books are available for most papers and free shipping is available.
 
Take advantage of our buyer rewards, reseller, 501c and military discount programs along with special offer promotions.

With decades of experience in the paper industry, our top-notch customer service, teamwork and attention to detail guarantees quality and professionalism in all we do.  

Our corporate office campus is located in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, along with a state-of-the-art 72,000-square-foot converting and distribution center in the heart of the "Paper Valley" in Neenah, Wisconsin.

Filter

17,956 Verified Customer Reviews

17,956 Customer Ratings and Reviews

Shopper Approved collects trusted reviews from customers who have made a verified purchase.

4.8

Overall Star
Rating

5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
14K+
(82.3%)
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2409
(13.4%)
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
597
(3.3%)
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
87
(0.5%)
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
79
(0.4%)

Would Buy Again
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
15K+
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
1808
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
463
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
71
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
79
Would Recommend
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
14K+
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2175
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
636
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
99
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
94
Delivery Time
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4360
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
600
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
183
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
51
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
47
Product Satisfaction
4.7
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4348
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
598
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
185
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
38
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
72
Customer Service
4.6
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
493
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
77
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
30
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
15
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
20
Price Satisfaction
4.4
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
3209
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
1299
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
527
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
132
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
74
SHOW DETAILS

5000+ 5-star reviews

About this Company

Great Papers. Fast Shipping. Low Prices. Real People.

Professionals and hobbyists alike have trusted The Paper Mill Store since 2004 to provide great papers at great prices, shipped fast and secure.

We're here to make your paper project easy and perfect. Choose from over 13,000 SKUs from more than 200 paper mill brands handled by attentive, dedicated professionals. With the majority of SKUs in-stock, most orders ship within 24 hours (usually same day).

In addition to thousands of brand-name papers, envelopes, card stocks and other products, we offer and array of custom services including paper cutting, perforating, scoring, drilling, envelope printing and custom watermarking. Samples and swatch books are available for most papers and free shipping is available.
 
Take advantage of our buyer rewards, reseller, 501c and military discount programs along with special offer promotions.

With decades of experience in the paper industry, our top-notch customer service, teamwork and attention to detail guarantees quality and professionalism in all we do.  

Our corporate office campus is located in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, along with a state-of-the-art 72,000-square-foot converting and distribution center in the heart of the "Paper Valley" in Neenah, Wisconsin.

Filter
J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jason F.
1 day ago

Always buying from the Paper Mill - product quality is always great and you have just what I need!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

N
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Nancy M.
1 day ago

I've shopped at this store for eight years and I've never been disappointed in the service, quality of products, or the shipping!!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

S
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Sharon W.
Today , TX

Always buy my paper from Paper Mill store. Good paper at reasonable price

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
4/5
Customer Service
5/5
Delivery
3/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Astroparche White Card Stock - 8 1/2 x 11 in 65 lb Cover Vellum  30% Recycled 250 per Package
Astroparche White Card Stock - 8 1/2 x 11 in 65 lb Cover Vellum 30% Recycled 250 per Package
Read more reviews about this product

Today

Nice paper for printing

Used this paper for a program cover. It printed very nicely, and is a good weight. Just so others know, it is not a "brilliant" white, but a little "off white". Great paper.


P
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer PlaidGal
Today , WI

Julie is always super helpful

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Customer Service
5/5
Delivery
3/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Curious Metallics Gold Leaf Paper - 8 1/2 x 11 in 80 lb Text Metallic C/2S 250 per Package
Curious Metallics Gold Leaf Paper - 8 1/2 x 11 in 80 lb Text Metallic C/2S 250 per Package
Read more reviews about this product

Today

Nice Two Sided Shimmer Paper

This paper is lightweight and is what I would describe as more of an antique gold ... very rich looking. The other paper stock that I had used in the past from another supplier was much brighter and heavier but it was 4x the cost. This cardstock was a great purchase to keep my costs down while still having a shimmer gold paper for my customers to choose from


K
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Kris
Today , WI

Decent price on "pricey" paper that gives our client's reports that little extra professional touch.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
4/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Royal Sundance White Card Stock - 8 1/2 x 11 in 80 lb Cover Smooth Fiber  30% Recycled 250 per Packa
Royal Sundance White Card Stock - 8 1/2 x 11 in 80 lb Cover Smooth Fiber 30% Recycled 250 per Packa
Read more reviews about this product

Today

Adds that little something extra to reports prepared for clients.

Always good quality


why Trust Verified Reviews?

Verified Reviews are real, authentic reviews collected from actual paying customers, using Shopper Approved's Verified Review Platform. When reviews are Verified by Shopper Approved, you know that you can trust them to make better buying decisions.

Unverified Reviews on the other hand, are reviews collected by Open Review platforms that allow anyone to leave a review, without any validation or proof of purchase. Unfortunately, most reviews you read online are Unverified Reviews, and can't be trusted.

As a consumer, here's how you can tell the difference:

Verified Reviews from Verified Review Platforms like Shopper Approved, have much higher review counts and higher overall Star ratings, because they attempt to collect reviews from every single paying customer.

Unverified Reviews from Open Review Platforms, tend to have much lower review counts and more negative Star ratings, because people with bad experiences are primarily those who leave reviews. This often creates a misleading, inaccurate portrayal of a companies true reputation.

So, when searching for Verified Reviews, look for the name you know you can trust. Shopper Approved.

Are you a Business?

See What Shopper Approved
Can Do For You

Inactive Business
Website

© 2022 ShopperApproved.com. All rights reserved. Learn more about Shopper Approved.

This Shopper Approved Customer Rating and Review Certificate was generated using independent survey information gathered by Shopper Approved, LLC © 2022