ThePaperMillStore.com Reviews

About this Company

Great Papers. Fast Shipping. Low Prices. Real People.

Professionals and hobbyists alike have trusted The Paper Mill Store since 2004 to provide great papers at great prices, shipped fast and secure.

We're here to make your paper project easy and perfect. Choose from over 13,000 SKUs from more than 200 paper mill brands handled by attentive, dedicated professionals. With the majority of SKUs in-stock, most orders ship within 24 hours (usually same day).

In addition to thousands of brand-name papers, envelopes, card stocks and other products, we offer and array of custom services including paper cutting, perforating, scoring, drilling, envelope printing and custom watermarking. Samples and swatch books are available for most papers and free shipping is available.
 
Take advantage of our buyer rewards, reseller, 501c and military discount programs along with special offer promotions.

With decades of experience in the paper industry, our top-notch customer service, teamwork and attention to detail guarantees quality and professionalism in all we do.  

Our corporate office campus is located in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, along with a state-of-the-art 72,000-square-foot converting and distribution center in the heart of the "Paper Valley" in Neenah, Wisconsin.

Filter

21,027 Verified Customer Reviews

21,027 Customer Ratings and Reviews

Shopper Approved collects trusted reviews from customers who have made a verified purchase.

4.8

Overall Star
Rating

5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
17K+
(82.7%)
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2757
(13.1%)
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
684
(3.3%)
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
98
(0.5%)
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
93
(0.4%)

Would Buy Again
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
18K+
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2055
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
533
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
98
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
89
Would Recommend
4.8
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
17K+
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
2493
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
729
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
113
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
111
Product Satisfaction
4.7
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4990
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
682
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
214
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
43
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
85
Delivery Time
4.7
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
4963
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
711
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
213
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
65
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
62
Customer Service
4.6
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
602
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
95
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
34
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
16
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
25
Price Satisfaction
4.4
5 Shopper Approved - Review Star
3690
4 Shopper Approved - Review Star
1483
3 Shopper Approved - Review Star
608
2 Shopper Approved - Review Star
147
1 Shopper Approved - Review Star
86
SHOW DETAILS

5-star reviews
17K+

5-star reviews

6 years collecting reviews
Filter
J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Julio J.
1 day ago

Good!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

T
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Theresa B.
1 day ago

So far everything is great.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

M
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Mark N.
1 day ago

great transaction- thank you

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

C
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Cindy B.
1 day ago

Easy to use great !

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer JAMES W.
1 day ago

The linen cardstock works great for note cards!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

E
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Enrico G.
1 day ago

Quick and clean experience adding all my contacts to be printed on each envelope!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

F
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Frances M.
1 day ago , SC

Like their website. Easy to navigate and order

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

ColorMates Smooth & Silky Black Card Stock - 12 x 12 in 80 lb Cover Smooth 25 per Package
ColorMates Smooth & Silky Black Card Stock - 12 x 12 in 80 lb Cover Smooth 25 per Package
Read more reviews about this product

1 day ago

Great paper, great price.


K
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Kevin F.
1 day ago

If the sample is good I will be a new customer.

Would Recommend
3/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Delivery
5/5

J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer JUDITH T.
2 days ago

MY EXPERIENCE WAS GOOD

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

A
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Amy G.
2 days ago

Great product, fast delivery. 10/10 would recommend

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jill S.
2 days ago

I am a bit nervous about my cut and score selections…if I did it correctly I will be thrilled! Thanks for offering those services.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

N
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Noibely G.
2 days ago

Is good

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

S
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Sherrie L.
2 days ago

Fine

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Customer Service
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Recommend Product

Yes

Astrobrights Lunar Blue Paper - 8 1/2 x 11 in 50 lb Text Smooth  30% Recycled 500 per Ream
Astrobrights Lunar Blue Paper - 8 1/2 x 11 in 50 lb Text Smooth 30% Recycled 500 per Ream
Read more reviews about this product

2 days ago

worked well


J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jon C.
3 days ago

Easy Website to use and prices are pretty good compared to other sites.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

J
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Jesus M.
3 days ago

Ok

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

B
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Beth H.
3 days ago

Great experience!

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

D
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Deric M.
3 days ago

Great. Quick and easy.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

V
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer victoria H.
3 days ago

easy, and you had what i wanted. online resale license agreement was easy, too.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

N
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Neal F.
3 days ago

so far, so good

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5

R
Shopper Approved - Verified Customer Rick T.
3 days ago

Great service and products.

Would Recommend
5/5
Would Buy Again
5/5
Product Satisfaction
5/5
Price
5/5
Customer Service
5/5
Delivery
5/5

Are you a Business?

See What Shopper Approved
Can Do For You

Inactive Business
Website Directions Phone

© 2024 ShopperApproved.com. All rights reserved. Learn more about Shopper Approved.

This Shopper Approved Customer Rating and Review Certificate was generated using independent survey information gathered by Shopper Approved, LLC © 2024